Resistance To Change In Organizations Comes From These 5 Factors
Leadership IQ studied more than 79,000 employees and leaders, and discovered that employees’ resistance to change management efforts comes from these 5 factors...
Every organization and leader experiences resistance to change. But as frustrating a problem as it may be, it can be overcome IF you understand the 5 major factors that drive resistance to change. Based on four Leadership IQ studies, involving more than 79,000 employees and leaders, this report will show you the underlying causes of resistance to change, and how your change management efforts can overcome them to achieve both minor and major change. Key findings from the study include:
- Only 15% of employees always understand the rationale behind their leaders' strategy
- 24% of an employee's belief that the company needs to change is driven by whether they understand the rationale behind those changes
- 23% of an employee's belief that the company needs to change is driven by their confidence is their personal ability to succeed in your change management initiatives
- Only 28% of respondents say that they like taking risks
- Only 15% of employees believe that their organization always openly shares the challenges facing it
- Only 22% of frontline employees like to leave their comfort zone
TABLE OF CONTENTS
- FINDING #1: EMPLOYEES DON'T UNDERSTAND THE RATIONALE BEHIND CHANGE
- FINDING #2: EMPLOYEES DOUBT THEY CAN BE SUCCESSFUL IN CHANGE
- FINDING #3: LEADERS AREN'T SHARING THEIR CHALLENGES
- FINDING #4: EMPLOYEES DON'T LOVE TAKING RISKS
- FINDING #5: EXECUTIVES LIKE LEAVING THEIR COMFORT ZONE
- VIDEO BREAKDOWN OF THE STUDY
- TAKE THE CHANGE MANAGEMENT QUIZ
- STUDY METHODOLOGY
video breakdown of the study
FINDING #1: RESISTANCE TO CHANGE COMES BECAUSE only 15% of Employees Understand the Rationale Behind Leaders’ Strategy
It makes sense to think that the more an employee understands the rationale behind our strategy, business decisions and change efforts, the more likely they'll be to support our change management efforts and less likely to experience change resistance. In Study #1, Leadership IQ asked 31,664 employees and leaders whether they understand the rationale behind their organization's strategy (e.g. economic, marketplace, competitive factors, etc.). Sadly, a paltry 15% Always understand the rationale behind their organization's strategy (e.g. economic, marketplace, competitive factors, etc.). This will be a major obstacle for achieving successful change.
As you can see, there are more people who Never or Rarely understand the rationale behind their organization's strategy than there are those who Always or Frequently do. If people don't understand why they need to change, they won't change. After all, if an organization seems to be plugging along, doing reasonably well, why would it need to make a seemingly sudden shift to something else (aka organizational change)? That would seem to be unwarranted at best, and destructive at worst. Not only is a change effort in that context likely to incur significant resistance from employees, it's also likely to damage executives' reputations severely. If a change effort, or radical shift in strategy, seems capricious or poorly thought-out, the leaders behind those changes are going to be tainted.
In this same study, Leadership IQ conducted a regression analysis between the following two questions: "I believe that this organization needs to change in order to remain successful" AND "I understand the rationale behind this organization's strategy (e.g. economic, marketplace, competitive factors, etc.)."
When we plotted these questions, we discovered a significant positive relationship. In essence, 24% of an employee's belief that the company needs to change is driven by whether they understand the rationale behind the change process (R-Squared: 0.240666, p-value: < 0.0001).
If you're seeing significant resistance to change from your employees, it could be because they don't understand the rationale behind your change initiative. But the more they DO understand the rationale behind your decision and the proposed change, the less resistance to change (whether covert resistance or overt resistance) you're going to experience.
FINDING #2: RESISTANCE TO CHANGE COMES BECAUSE Employees Doubt They Can Be Successful In This Change Effort
It makes sense to think that the more confident employees feel about their ability to successfully navigate your change management efforts, the less resistance to change you'll see. Using the same study as Finding #1, Leadership IQ asked 31,664 employees and leaders the following 2 questions: "I believe that this organization needs to change in order to remain successful" AND "I am confident that I will personally be successful with the organizational change currently underway at this organization."
When we plotted these questions, we again discovered a significant positive relationship. In essence, 23% of an employee's belief that the company needs to change is driven by their confidence in their personal ability to succeed in your change management initiatives (R-Squared: 0.227627, p-value: < 0.0001).
If you're seeing significant resistance to change from your employees, it could from a lack of confidence on their part (this is especially true in cases of transformational change). And a lack of confidence often comes from insufficient training, support, learning opportunities and psychological safety. If your scores on these questions are particularly low, you could expect even more overt resistance to your organizational change effort. Overcoming resistance from this issue will obviously take some time and effort, but it is eminently achievable.
FINDING #3: RESISTANCE TO CHANGE COMES BECAUSE Leaders Don’t Share The Challenges Facing The Organization
When employees understand the challenges facing the organization, they're going to be more inclined to support a change process to address those challenges. In the data from Study #2, Leadership IQ surveyed 27,048 senior leaders, middle manager and frontline employees and found that only 15% of employees believe that their organization Always openly shares the challenges facing it.
It's going to be difficult to overcome change resistance when employees don't understand the root cause challenges that precipitated the change initiative. And not only does this impact resistance to change, it also impacts how employees feel about working at the company. This study discovered that 63% of employees who think their organization Always openly shares the challenges facing it will strongly recommend it as a great organization to work for. By contrast, only 6% of employees who think their organization Never openly shares the challenges facing it will strongly recommend it as a great organization to work for. In other words, if an employee believes their company openly shares the challenges facing it, they're about 10 times more likely to recommend it as a great employer (a key measure of employee engagement). So managing resistance not only decreases employee resistance to change and a possible negative emotional reaction from frontline employees, it also increases employee engagement.
FINDING #4: RESISTANCE TO CHANGE COMES BECAUSE Employees Don’t Love Taking Risks
One of the questions on our online test "What's Your Style Of Change Management?" asks respondents to choose between these 3 options: "I like taking risks" OR "I would take a risk if it seemed prudent" OR "I avoid risks." Overall, about 28% of respondents say that they like taking risks. If your company is going through a change management initiative that seems risky, you're likely to hit resistance to change if only 28% of people like taking risks.
However, we discovered big differences in how people viewed change when we dissected the data by position. For instance, 40% of top executives like taking risks. But for frontline employees, that number is only 24%. So in the average company, the CEO is 66% more likely to enjoy taking risks than the employees. (This will hold true generally for any senior members of the organizational leadership). Note also that a middle manager is much closer to a frontline employee than to a senior manager.
There are several lessons here: First, if your change management initiative seems risky, especially in the eyes of employees, you're probably going to incur resistance to change. You might look at the riskiness and think 'wow, this idea is really cool; finally some excitement!' or even 'This technological change will put us at the top of our industry.' But given what the above data shows, it's quite likely that your employees don't view the riskiness quite so favorably. Typically senior leaders and even the middle manager serve as the change agent for organizational change. And it's absolutely critical to remember that a change leader is definitionally going to embrace riskiness more than someone who prizes and enjoys the status quo.
Second, if you're the executive who's initiating this change management program, you probably have a very different assessment of what constitutes 'risk' than your employees. To you, this change might seem like the easiest thing ever. But are your employees going to see it that way? A great many of your employees will experience individual resistance to your change plan, not because your change management team did something wrong or because the change management process was predicated on a bad idea, but rather because their personalities prize security over adventure. [Check out the test What Motivates You? for more detail on individual personalities].
FINDING #5: RESISTANCE TO CHANGE COMES BECAUSE TOP EXECUTIVES ARE 91% MORE LIKELY TO ENJOY LEAVING THEIR COMFORT ZONE
Change management efforts require that people leave their comfort zones (otherwise it wouldn't be a change, it would just be the normal daily routine). And comfort zones are, by definition, comfortable. So it would make sense that the less someone likes to leave their comfort zone, the more likely they are to evidence resistance to change.
The 12,801 people who took the test in Study #4 were asked to choose between the statements, "I don't like to leave my comfort zone," OR, "I will leave my comfort zone on occasion," OR, "I like to leave my comfort zone." And as you can see in the chart below, top executives are 91% more likely to enjoy leaving their comfort zone. As you might imagine, a small percentage of people (27%) like to leave their comfort zone. But the real change management challenge appears when we break-out the data by position:
As you can see, frontline employees generally do NOT like to leave their comfort zone (22%). But top executives DO like to leave their comfort zone (42%). And that's one big reason why employees are far more likely to be resisting change than a senior manager.
That creates a palpable tension in many organizations. If executives like to leave their comfort zone, they're going to push for transformational change (i.e., changes that are big and bold). And that's going to create even more resistance to change on the part of their employees.
An effective change management process will recognize that whether the change is new technology, social change, or a reshuffling of the organizational structure, many stakeholders simply enjoy the status quo and don't like leaving their comfort zone. Resistance management (aka overcoming organizational resistance to change) is going to require acknowledging that many people have a negative emotional reaction to anything risky, and that includes change.
This is perhaps even more important when it comes to culture change. It's unreasonable to expect that you can create a more agile and change-ready organization simply by saying "we want a culture change to make our company move faster."
OVERCOMING CHANGE RESISTANCE EVEN FASTER
For many a CEOs and senior manager, change is never fast enough. Based on the 20,000 people who've taken the online assessment "How Do You Personally Feel About Change?", we know that around 40% of senior executives think the pace of change at their company is too slow, and fewer than 5% think it's too fast. As you might imagine, those numbers are nearly reversed for frontline employees.
If you need your company to move faster-to capture new market opportunities, surmount the competition, etc., those numbers above should give any executive pause. Will your company succeed if your key stakeholders are fighting your transformational change?
And if your company is in a traditional industry with long-tenured employees, it's likely that you're even more frustrated that your organization isn't moving fast enough or that there's too much employee resistance.
How do you instill more urgency and speed into your company's DNA? First, communicate, communicate and communicate some more. One of the great dangers for a CEO, senior manager or human resources leader is poor communication (or no communication). We all have the voice inside our head telling us not to talk about bad news, but too often, that turns into radio silence, and it's hard for people to trust their leaders when they're not hearing anything. Remember that increasing communication is almost always a good thing.
Of course, just communicating frequently isn't enough. Leaders also need to explain why we're doing what we're doing. There are times, of course, when you can't openly communicate all the reasons you're doing things. But it's generally a good idea to fully explain why we're doing what we're doing and eliminate as much uncertainty as possible.
Remember that when change managers undertake their decision making about whether to commence a change initiative, they might spend months pondering new competitors, industry regulations, digital adoption, pricing strategies, customer sentiment, and thousands more data points. But when that planned change is launched, employees don't get any of the data that drove executives' decision making. No wonder most companies experience employee resistance.
As we can see in all of the above charts, it's critical that your employees know the rationale behind why this planned change is important. This is so critical that no leader, in any company, should be allowed to talk about a change initiative or strategy or much of anything unless they include a sentence that begins, "The rationale behind why we're doing this is..."
Without a clear rationale, change managers are flirting with failure. And as we know from the study "Why CEOs Get Fired," mismanaging change is the top reason why CEOs lose their jobs.
TAKE THE change management QUIZ
This report was developed using four different studies on managing change. In STUDY #1, Leadership IQ surveyed 31,664 employees and leaders. STUDY #1 respondents represented the following demographics: POSITION: Executives (11%), Middle Managers (41%), Frontline Employees (48%). In STUDY #2, Leadership IQ surveyed 27,048 executives, managers and employees from January-June, 2017. STUDY #2 respondents represented the following demographics: COMPANY SIZE [EMPLOYEES]: 1-499 employees (40.0%), 500-4,999 employees (30.8%), 5,000+ employees (29.2%). In STUDY #3, 7,745 people took an online test called ""What's Your Style Of Change Management?" STUDY #3 respondents represented the following demographics: GENDER: Female (48%), Male (52%). In STUDY #4, 12,801 people took an online test called "Do You Set SMART Goals Or HARD Goals?" STUDY #4 respondents represented the following demographics: GENDER: Female (54%), Male (46%)-- COMPANY SIZE [EMPLOYEES]: 1-9 (5%), 10-50 (9%), 51-100 (13%), 101-500 (21%), 501-2,000 (17%), 2,001-5,000 (9%), 5,001-10,000 (7%), 10,000+ (19%).
- Leadership Styles Quiz: Which Of These Different Leadership Styles Do You Use?
- Communication Styles Quiz And Research: Which Of These Different Communication Styles Do You Use?
- Types Of Power Quiz: Do You Use Referent Power, Reward Power, Coercive Power, Legitimate Power, Expert Power or Information Power?
- Quiz: What Motivates You?
- The State Of Leadership Development
- Why New Hires Fail (The Landmark "Hiring For Attitude" Study Updated With New Data)
- Are SMART Goals Dumb?
- Employee Engagement Is Higher For Low Performers In 42% Of Companies
- Quiz: What's Your Organizational Culture?