Quiz: Is Your Personality Suited To Working Remotely Or In The Office?

Some people have the personality to work remotely. These remote personalities are hard-charging go-getters with a self-motivated mindset. They’re fine working with fewer rules and more all-nighters. And they’re not fazed by the isolation, diminished emotional and administrative support, or the reduced collaboration and recognition of remote work.

When these remote personalities work remotely they’re very happy. 43% of them say they love their job. But when remote personalities have to go work inside an office, their happiness drops precipitously; only 24% of them love their job.

This data comes from the 8,117 people that have taken the free online test “Is Your Personality Suited To Working Remotely Or In The Office?” Respondents answer 10 questions and receive results indicating whether their personality is better suited to working remotely or working in an office. We can then see whether their personality matches with their actual working situation.

Here’s a chart with the data…

JobSatisfactionByLocation

The data also shows that only a small percentage of remote personalities who work remotely dislike or just tolerate their jobs. This is what we would expect, just as it seems predictable that remote personalities working in an office rank the highest of people who hate, dislike or just tolerate their jobs.

But what about the people who have a personality better suited to working in an office? These office personalities like the collegial work environment, consistency, sane workloads and clearly defined expectations often associated with working in office. But here’s a shocker, when office personalities work remotely, 31% of them say they love their job.

Apparently, it’s better to have an office personality and work remotely than it is to have a remote personality and work in an office. One reason for this may be how the two personality types respond to having rules and clearly defined expectations. The online test actually asked, "Do you like having rules and clearly defined expectations or you prefer not to be constrained by a set of rigid rules?" And what we learned is that office personalities do a much better job adapting to the remote work freedom of fewer rules than do remote employees in adapting to the constraint of in-office rules.

Anecdotally, one office personality I spoke to told me she thought she would hate working from home when her organization downsized its physical office and sent her home to work. “I loved the routine of working in office and I definitely appreciated the unwritten rule that once you leave the office in the evening, work is done for the day,” she said. But this office personality found that acclimating to remote work wasn’t that difficult. “I’ve been working from home for almost a year and my boss remains quite happy with my work quality. I actually don’t mind not being chained to the 8-to-6 grind I was in before. It’s not like I was actually working all those hours anyway. Sometimes now I work days, sometimes I work nights, but I get just as much done as I did in office and I actually have more time for myself.”

This is a big leap from the remote personality who described being forced to work in office as “soul sucking.” As he explained, “No matter how much work you do or don’t have, when you work in office you aren’t the one who sets your schedule. Even the most efficient worker can’t leave before 5 o’clock without getting suspicious looks. I lost all the passion for my work when I was forced to work in office.”

Both stories support the data that tells us that having more freedom than you’d like is tolerable. And it’s a lot better than getting less freedom than you’d like.

Also of surprise in the data were the levels of unhappiness of office personalities who do work in an office. We might expect them to be pretty happy because they actually get to work in an environment that matches their predisposition, but only 19% say they love their jobs, and that’s the lowest number of any of these groups. It does seem that regardless of your personality, working in an office is a recipe for not loving your job.

Of course, working in an office can’t be all bad. There are still people that work in offices and absolutely love their jobs. But this data raises some questions about whether there are aspects of working remotely that are just better for people and whether we could bring some of those elements into the office.

For example, many managers are just bad at managing. They don’t know how to coach, inspire, give feedback, etc. And it’s not necessarily their fault; they were never taught how to actually manage people. So instead of good managing, they often micromanage. They hover over their employees, needling them with questions about the most picayune details, and ultimately suck any autonomy (and thus engagement) out of their employees. Now, if an employee were working remotely, they could avoid a lot of that micromanaging. The boss can’t walk over to their desk and just stand there, because the boss is many miles away. Sure, the boss can still email incessantly, but that’s a lot easier to ignore.

There are dozens of ways we could infuse the office environment with elements of working remotely. Humans probably didn’t evolve to sit for eight hours continuously; it’s more likely we’re suited to work in intense bursts with breaks and the chance to stand or walk. Maybe having some personal items on the desk isn’t so bad. (Yes, there are still many offices than ban or limit personal items on desks.) And maybe we could train managers how to manage, including how to coach, set inspiring goals, give useful feedback and even some positive reinforcement.

Related Posts

Posted by Mark Murphy on 11 April, 2018 Interpersonal Skills, Quizzes, Telecommuting | 8 comments
Previous post Next Post

Comments

  • Kathy Ormiston - April 18, 2017

    I prefer working in the office, and thought I answered the questions with that mindset. The test results though said I would be a good candidate to work remotely. I do occasionally work at home (big project needing a day or two of heads down) and I would not like to do it everyday. Too quiet. No people. No face-to-face interaction….that is what I thrive on. I also know that my ‘hallway’ conversations have generated the best ideas, new exciting projects, more solutions, contributed to my network, etc. and that is non-existent when working remotely. I do know that it is about flexibility and everyone’s needs are different.

  • Dias Wade - September 22, 2016

    Working from home or in the office can be equally rewarding; however, as the quiz states if all depends on one’s personality. Working from home is almost equivalent to going to college online, they both require a great deal of self-discipline, time management, and drive.

  • Sam - April 18, 2016

    Interesting quiz and article. Honestly, I feel it is always variable with different factors coming into play. Even if one is suited for the office environment, it is certainly does not seem right and unfortunately toxic for that person if he/she has to face a micromanager wrongly looking over shoulder or any toxic co-workers.

    Also, even for people telecommuting as long as they have a place that is conducive regarding background noise and less distractions that’s what matters.

  • Anthony Bergamasco - February 05, 2016

    This was a really interesting quiz. Thanks for posting!

  • Joanne Legault - February 04, 2016

    I like working from home, because I spend less time traveling giving me more time to work if I need too. I’m helping my colleagues it doesn’t matter where I am, they are always able to reach me across Canada. I’m getting old and it would be a good reason for me to stay more longer into ADP organization and share my knowledge.

  • Leslie - February 02, 2016

    This is a fun test

  • Aniket Ajit Umbare - February 02, 2016

    I strongly feel that working in office is more efficient way instead remotely.
    We always feel to work when we have emergency ofr we feel to. But in this situation the quality of work goes down due to lack of concentration towards work.

  • Margaret Menagh - January 19, 2016

    It is improtant to be flexible in any work environment

Leave a comment

Stay in touch

Call us

We'd love to hear from you. Call us at 1-800-814-7859 and we'll be happy to answer any questions you have.

Latest posts

  • Video: Stop Blamers With These 3 Words

    Stop being frustrated when people won't take ownership for their mistakes. Use the technique in this video to stop blamers! And this video is a clip from our amazing online leadership course called The Science Of Great Managers! Learn more... Read more →

  • Video: 4 Words That Stop Drama Queens At Work

      This is only one of a HUNDRED TECHNIQUES you'll learn at the premier 2-day training for leaders called “What Great Managers Do Differently” Based on leading research & hyper-practical tools, you'll learn to inspire employees to give 100% effort,... Read more →

  • Quiz: What Motivates You?

    Through research with thousands of employees and leaders, we’ve discovered that there are five major motivations that drive people’s actions at work; Achievement, Power, Affiliation, Security, and Adventure. So take the test below to discover what motivates you. Read more →